Big Cars & Trucks Are Killing Americans In Record Numbers

Join daily news updates from CleanTechnica on e mail. Or follow us on Google News!

The Economist will not be a publication a lot given to hyperbole, so when it says the big vehicles and vehicles which might be held in such excessive regard by Individuals are literally chargeable for about half of the freeway deaths within the US annually, we must always maybe listen and never dismiss its pronouncement as simply mere hype and hyperbole.

For those who drive in America, the probabilities are that one in 75 of all of the folks within the vehicles round you on the street will likely be killed by a automotive — principally by another person’s automotive. Wherever you could be, the oldsters who’re cocooned in a large SUV or pickup truck are likelier to outlive a collision with one other automobile. However the weight of these machines has a price; it makes the roads extra harmful for everybody else. The Economist has discovered that, for each life the heaviest 1% of SUVs or vehicles saves in America, greater than a dozen lives are misplaced by folks driving in smaller automobiles.

Annually, vehicles kill roughly 40,000 folks in America, and never simply because it’s a huge place the place folks like to drive. The nation’s roads are almost twice as harmful per mile pushed as these in different developed international locations. Deaths in America involving vehicles and vehicles have elevated over the previous decade regardless of the introduction of applied sciences meant to make driving safer.

Heavier Vehicles & Vans Are Extra Harmful

Weight is responsible, The Economist says. It backs up that declare with knowledge for 7.5 million automotive crashes in 14 American states between 2013 and 2023. Its examine discovered that for each 10,000 crashes, the heaviest automobiles kill 37 folks within the different automotive, in contrast with 5.7 for vehicles of a median weight and simply 2.6 for the lightest. The state of affairs is getting worse. In 2023, 31% of recent vehicles in America weighed over 5,000 lb (2.27 tons), in contrast with 22% in 2018. The variety of pedestrians killed by cars has nearly doubled since 2010.

Though a typical automotive is 25% lighter in Europe and 40% lighter in Japan, electrification will add weight there too, exacerbating the hole between the heaviest automobiles and the lightest. The Ford F-150 Lightning weighs round 40% greater than its gasoline-powered cousins due to the burden of the battery wanted to present it sufficient vary and hauling capability to compete with typical pickup vehicles. This poses an enormous downside. Individually, it’s rational for folks to purchase larger vehicles. But the results of these particular person selections is many extra fatalities in addition to costlier automotive insurance coverage for all drivers.

The Politics Of Huge Vehicles & Vans

In idea, regulators may insist that automobiles be made lighter. Good luck with that, The Economist says. Pickup drivers love sitting behind the wheel of an enormous truck. Operating for election on a platform of banning huge vehicles would lead to a crushing defeat on the polls. The pickup truck at present holds the identical mystique for Individuals, particularly males, as did the Marlboro Man within the final century. It’s a signal of virility, sexual attract, and private energy that appeals strongly to those that in any other case really feel they’re powerless. In America, it’s laborious sufficient to influence gun house owners to embrace wise gun legal guidelines, due to a perception that weapons make folks safer. For giant vehicles, that argument is even tougher to make, as a result of up to a degree, it’s really true.

How can American roads be made safer? As folks turn into conscious of the danger their selections impose on everybody else, attitudes to proudly owning gigantic vehicles could change. The Economist estimates that if the heaviest 10% of automobiles in America’s fleet shrank by roughly 1,000 lb, street fatalities in multi-car crashes would fall by 12%, or 2,300 a yr, with out sacrificing the protection of the heavier vehicles.

Attitudes could be nudged with reforms. Bizarrely, the federal government physique that charges vehicles for security didn’t suggest taking the protection of pedestrians or different automobiles into consideration till final yr. Due to a commerce dispute with Europe over exports of poultry, many lighter foreign-made vehicles should not even offered in America, a wrinkle often known as the “chicken tax.” Tax deductions for working automobiles encourage folks to purchase heavier vehicles with a GWVR of 7000 lb or extra. Gas requirements launched within the Nineteen Seventies to spice up extra environment friendly automobiles gave pickup vehicles a carve-out, which inadvertently elevated their gross sales.

How To Make Automobiles Safer

CleanTechnica readers will acknowledge this because the so-called “footprint rule” that permits larger, heavier automobiles to fulfill emissions and gas economic system requirements which might be considerably decrease than these for passenger vehicles. The development may tilt in the other way, nonetheless. In 2022, France launched a surcharge on new automobiles of €10 ($11) per kg over 1,800 kg (4,000 lb). In 2023, Norway started taxing automotive patrons at a fee of NKr12.50 ($1.17) per kg over 500 kg. We’re simply starting to see the facility of taxation as a coverage device in locations like Berkeley, California.

But, even when all these issues had been to alter, client preferences are so sturdy that changes to gas effectivity requirements would most likely not be sufficient. That means one other line of assault. Along with making vehicles lighter, producers could make accidents much less frequent and fewer lethal. In America, step one ought to be to revamp the street system. Within the early Nineteen Nineties, the French had been about as possible as Individuals to die in a automotive crash. Now they’re 3 times much less possible. Driving in Mississippi is 4 instances as harmful as in Massachusetts. In each instances, the design of roads explains a lot of the distinction.

It could appear arcane, however the lack of roundabouts in suburban and rural America is an enormous explanation for deaths. Changing intersections would save 1000’s of lives a yr. The unfold of four-lane highways that sit subsequent to buying malls and blend collectively pedestrians and vehicles turning out into heavy visitors is harmful too. American freeway engineers are likely to affiliate extensive lanes with security. The truth is, extra space encourages folks to drive sooner.

Gradual Down!

A second step that will be related all over the place is getting folks to decelerate. As a result of the vitality — and subsequently the harmful energy — of a transferring automobile rises with the sq. of its velocity, discovering methods to restrict pace has an outsize impact. A superb begin could be to implement the legal guidelines on pace limits that really exist, however many American states ban pace cameras. A extra bold however much less common thought is differential pace limits for vehicles and vehicles relying on weight. Think about the indignity of being overtaken by a Prius as you sit behind the wheel of your Chevy Silverado pickup, since you should journey 5 mph extra slowly to keep away from being fined or dropping your driving license.

In the end, carmakers can innovate away an issue that they’ve achieved a lot to create. Higher crash avoidance expertise and extra pedestrian safety techniques would assist. True self-driving vehicles, after they ultimately turn into frequent, will significantly cut back the variety of accidents and therefore the loss of life toll, even with heavy automobiles. Sadly, The Economist admits, that may very well be years away. Within the meantime, the duty of saving lives will fall primarily to street engineers and visitors cops.

The Takeaway

Individuals hate small vehicles. At all times have. Whereas Volkswagen was making the Beetle and BMW had its pretty early compact sedans, Individuals had been driving Cadillacs with trunks giant sufficient for six youngsters to sneak right into a drive-in movie show with out paying. When the fuel disaster hit within the ’70s, US producers introduced smaller vehicles to market, however many individuals felt they had been being punished by being pressured to drive them. David Wilcox wrote a paean to the American car that celebrated its enormousness, calling it a tail fin road locomotive — an apt description if ever there was one.

The examine by The Economist is necessary analysis that may spur some states to think about larger registration charges for heavier automobiles, a coverage that will influence electrical automotive drivers essentially the most. What if it value $500 a yr extra to register an EV than an analogous typical automotive due to the burden penalty? EV house owners would scream, and but if they’re a larger danger to different motorists, to not point out pedestrians and bicyclists, perhaps the concept is value contemplating.

One other space that would use some consideration is the design for the entrance of many SUVs and vehicles. Many characteristic excessive and extensive frontal areas that appear like the bow of an oil tanker bearing down on anybody unfortunate sufficient to get of their manner. It appears intuitively apparent that designers are making the entrance of at present’s vehicles and vehicles look as aggressive as potential to therapeutic massage the egos of those that discover themselves behind the wheel of those huge automobiles. Highly effective automobiles for many who really feel powerless in a world the place change occurs a lot sooner than it ever did earlier than? Completely.

We’ve got a minimum of one CleanTechnica reader who advocates tirelessly for smaller, lighter, extra environment friendly vehicles and vehicles. Is America prepared to just accept the downsizing of its automobiles to avoid wasting lives? If historical past is any information, the reply is an emphatic no.