Canada Plants A Big Wet Kiss On Oil Pipelines

Join daily news updates from CleanTechnica on e-mail. Or follow us on Google News!

Final Up to date on: twenty third February 2025, 02:03 am

Canada is livid with the unstable genius within the White Home for suggesting it ought to turn into America’s 51st US state. Including insult to damage, the aged Orange Moron has proposed slapping a 25 percent tariff on all the pieces the US imports from Canada. That’s a whole lot of stuff. Canada has an enormous automotive sector that’s deeply built-in into the US auto trade. The Gordie Howe Worldwide Bridge between Detroit, Michigan, and Windsor, Ontario, is a crucial a part of that trade as vehicles carrying automobile parts shuttle forwards and backwards throughout the border 24 hours a day. As well as, plenty of Canadian wooden merchandise, filthy crude oil from Alberta, and electrical energy discover their method south into the US.

As Lloyd Alter identified so eloquently in a latest Substack postCanada must develop new buying and selling companions so it may be much less economically depending on the US. That’s a superb thought, however it might result in unlucky penalties for the setting. The Trudeau authorities is responding by funding two main oil pipelines that may transport the nation’s petroleum merchandise to ports the place they are often transshipped to abroad prospects. One goes east and one goes west, however each fly over the Massive Oil cuckoo’s nest. It’s unlikely that’s the end result Lloyd Alter had in thoughts.

Trans Mountain Enlargement Is Again In The Information

Readers might recall that in 2018, the Canadian authorities bought the Trans Mountain Enlargement pipeline for $34 billion (CND). That pipeline is designed to move the crud pumped from the Alberta tar sands (it needs to be dilutes first to get it to circulate) throughout the Rocky Mountains to ports on the west coast. On the time, many questioned why the federal government would need to tackle a undertaking that the non-public sector couldn’t make worthwhile. Maybe an analogy may be drawn to the interstate freeway system within the US, which gives an avenue for commerce throughout all the nation. Nonetheless, Canadian taxpayers paid for it and now they’re being saddled with much more debt — an extra $20 billion (CDN) — to assist the Trans Mountain Enlargement (TMX) pipeline.

In line with Canadian environmental advocacy group Environmental Defencethis raises the Canadian authorities’s complete monetary dedication to the pipeline to $50 billion, which has drawn sharp criticism from environmentalists and economists. “At a time when Canada should be accelerating its clean energy transition, providing $20 billion in public financing for the TMX pipeline is a step in the wrong direction,” Laura Cameron, a coverage advisor with the International Institute for Sustainable Development who focuses on fossil gasoline subsidies, advised DeSmog in an e-mail. She stated the TMX mortgage locations extra long-term monetary danger on taxpayers and additional subsidizes a worthwhile trade amid an affordability disaster.

Why Is Canada Doing This Now?

The brand new mortgage comes after threats of a commerce warfare between the US and Canada led to requires Canada to be much less economically depending on commerce with the US. “(The loan is) a violation of the federal government’s promise not to provide further public money to the project,” Julia Levin, affiliate director of Nationwide Local weather with Environmental Defence, stated. She added that this brings the overall quantity of the Canadian authorities’s monetary assist to the oil and gasoline trade final yr to $28.5 billion. “This newest massive loan will only benefit CEOs from the oil and banking industry, while Canadians already struggling with an affordability crisis will be left on the hook to cover the costs,” she stated.

Analysis carried out by IISD reveals that, regardless of Canada’s frequent pledges to finish fossil gasoline subsidies, the nation continues funneling tens of billions of taxpayer {dollars} into the pockets of massively worthwhile oil and gasoline corporations, massively silly waste of public cash. “A recent IISD report found that TMX is operating at a loss and will only recover the full investment if government acts to make oil companies pay the full cost,” Cameron stated. As an alternative of supporting the oil trade, “shifting public financing to support industries with long-term growth trajectories will bolster domestic economic security, create good stable jobs, and reduce our reliance on volatile fossil fuels.”

An analysis by DeSmog reveals that TMX might by no means have been financially viable within the first place. The undertaking was almost deserted by Kinder Morgan, its authentic developer, in 2018. Regardless of that, the Trudeau authorities capitulated to strain from the fossil gasoline sector and their lobbyists, who argued that the nation’s inadequate pipeline infrastructure made Canada overly reliant on the US. As well as, anticipated Asian demand for fossil fuels from Canada by no means materialized and the pipeline has been working at a loss since its launch in Might 2024.

TMX is now the costliest infrastructure undertaking in Canadian historical past, estimated to value 40 occasions greater than investments in renewable vitality between 2014 and 2020. Specialists say it’s unlikely to recoup its prices, not to mention flip a revenue, as a result of the federal government fees tolls amounting to lower than half of what’s required to pay the pipeline’s capital prices. “Oil industry CEOs and their political supporters have been quick to exploit the current uncertainty sparked by President Trump’s tariff threat by insisting the answer is more oil and gas pipelines,” Environmental Defence’s Levin stated in a press release. “Let TMX be a warning. It’s taxpayers who end up paying the price, as multinational, foreign owned companies reap the rewards. More fossil fuel infrastructure is not a winning strategy for Canadians or the planet.”

Keith Stewart, senior vitality strategist with Greenpeace Canada, thinks it’s attainable that tariff threats from the Trump administration might result in extra Canadian oil flowing towards Asian markets. However he thinks the oil corporations ought to pay for pipelines, not taxpayers. “This is a very old playbook, where the oil industry is looking to take advantage of a crisis to brush aside environmental and health protections. (Fossil fuel leaders) backed Trump’s campaign for President with mega-donations, and now they want to bring Trump-style environmental rules here. But we should no more accept this than we do his demand that Canada become the 51st state. Doubling down on oil now, as the world is switching to electric vehicles and heat pumps, would be like buying a Blockbuster franchise as Netflix is taking off,” he stated.

Julia Levin agrees the oil trade and its political supporters usually attempt to revenue from world crises. “We’ve seen it before, for example, in response to the crisis in Ukraine. The response from the fossil fuel industry is always the same — do away with regulations, build more pipelines, remove limits to pollution, and scrap environmental assessments. Of course, none of those things would actually help with the current situation.” Conservative Social gathering chief Pierre Poilievre additionally guarantees to decontrol the fossil gasoline trade if he turns into Prime Minister. “He has said he will kill the oil and gas pollution cap, the clean electricity regulation, the low carbon fuel rule, and the Impact Assessment Act while building pipelines in all directions,” Stewart famous.

Power East Pipeline Might Be Resurrected

Talking of all instructions, a proposed Power East pipeline from Alberta to St. John, New Brunswick, that has been dormant for years is abruptly again on the desk on account of Canada’s newfound curiosity in decoupling its financial system from its reliance on America. DeSmog suggests that almost all Canadians agree Canada must take Trump’s threats critically however that doesn’t imply the nation ought to write one other clean test for an oil trade mega-project that will take a decade to finish. The Canadian authorities is considering contributing one other $15 billion to get the Power East undertaking restarted.

The Monetary Occasions just lately reported that crude oil imports into China declined by 2 p.c in January. It stated, “Some may disagree on the exact moment when China’s appetite for oil peaks, but the IEA … says long term demand is only going in one direction and producers and oil-exporting countries need to be prepared.” The Globe and Mail just lately made the argument that “the economic case for new or revitalized pipelines is simply non-existent.” A wiser funding could be a large buildout of {the electrical} grid throughout Canada. To succeed in the projected vitality demand by 2050, the nation wants as much as 29 gigawatts of recent high-voltage transmission capability, together with 6,000 km of recent or upgraded energy corridors. This may greater than triple the  present inter-provincial capability, which has been hobbled by a scarcity of coordinated electrical energy buying and selling.

The present occupant of the Offal Workplace has stocked the US authorities with oil and gas executives — which isn’t stunning since they paid tens of millions in bribes political contributions to get him elected. When World Warfare II began, Australia thought it was a part of the British empire. Britain thought in any other case and principally advised Australia they have been on their very own and good luck. Canada is in an analogous scenario right this moment, considering it had a detailed relationship with the US solely to seek out its demonized on the whim of a deranged chief who imagines himself to be the second coming of King George III.

Trump has delivered a wakeup name to Canada, which completely does have to rethink its financial and cultural ties with America. Including extra fossil gasoline air pollution to the setting is an irresponsible response, nevertheless. Canada has the talents, the information, and the sources to construct a low-carbon financial system that might be the envy of the world. That’s the place it ought to make investments its ethical and monetary capital, no more fossil gasoline infrastructure.