Wind and solar power opponents make headway in state legislatures

On a latest day when the wind gusted near 40 miles per hour, 82-year-old George Neill was making repairs on his ranch, oblivious to the close by cluster of wind generators churning the sky behind him.

“After about a year, you never know the things are here,” stated Neill, who leases a part of his West Texas property to an East Coast-based renewable power firm that positioned three wind generators on it 4 years in the past.

Tons of of different wind generators stretch throughout this panorama, immediately seen to motorists touring to close by San Angelo and different cities. The generators aren’t the one renewable power producers amid the mesas. From a distance, a glistening array of photo voltaic panels resembles a small lake.

Texas is legendary for producing oil and fuel, however renewable power has develop into deeply embedded within the state’s tradition and financial system. Texas led the nation in producing electrical energy from wind energy and utility-scale solar energy in 2023, and wind and solar energy projects contribute tax revenue to local governments and struggling school districts.

Texas landowners are anticipated to obtain almost $30 billion in lease funds underneath present and anticipated initiatives, in keeping with an trade examine.

However lately, Texas has loosened its political embrace of other power. For the second legislative session in a row, many Texas lawmakers are attempting to derail or curb future renewable power initiatives.

The shift is rooted in plenty of elements, together with the second Trump administration’s antipathy towards renewables and an aggressive recommitment to fossil fuels in Texas power coverage.

There may be lingering concern over the reliability of the state’s electrical grid, in any case kinds of energy sources failed throughout a devastating 2021 winter storm. Some folks object to the aesthetics of wind and photo voltaic farms, or observe that generators and panels can hurt some wildlife.

Texas just isn’t alone. As soon as centered on stopping particular person initiatives on the native degree, renewable power opponents have been making inroads in different state legislatures, too. They’ve acquired backing from the oil and fuel trade. They usually’ve been galvanized by the 2022 passage of the Inflation Discount Act, the largest-ever try to hurry the transition to wash power.

In neighboring Oklahoma, for instance, a whole lot of individuals rallied on the state Capitol in January to induce Republican Gov. Kevin Stitt to situation an government order halting new wind and photo voltaic initiatives. Like Texas, Oklahoma is a serious oil and pure fuel producer, however it generated 45% of its complete in-state electrical energy from renewable assets in 2023.

Stitt, a robust supporter of renewable power, is extremely unlikely to situation such an order. However he’ll go away workplace in two years, and a number of other Republicans mentioned as potential successors appeared on the rally. One among them, Legal professional Basic Gentner Drummond, just lately on social media criticized what he referred to as “the green energy scam” and urged Stitt and state lawmakers to tighten wind farm guidelines in the course of the present session.

In Arizona, the Home earlier this 12 months accredited a invoice that will bar wind farm initiatives inside a dozen miles of any property zoned for residential use—a restriction that will apply to about 90% of the land within the state, in keeping with an evaluation by the Arizona Republic.

In Ohio, a 2021 legislation permitting county commissioners to create restricted areas the place utility-scale photo voltaic and wind initiatives cannot be constructed has had a huge effect, as 26 Ohio counties have banned renewable power initiatives. This 12 months, GOP lawmakers have launched laws that will finish all state photo voltaic subsidies.

And in Missouri, Republican legislators are pushing a invoice that will increase taxes on farmers who lease their land for wind or photo voltaic power initiatives.

The increasing opposition to renewables is not surprising, stated Joshua Rhodes, a analysis scientist on the College of Texas at Austin who research the facility grid. He famous that wind, photo voltaic and battery storage have quickly develop into the “cheapest way to put more energy on the grid.”

“They’re victims of their own success,” he informed Stateline. “They are relatively new players to the market, so there’s going to be pushback from incumbents.”

Opposing sides

On the middle of the present debate in Texas is state Sen. Lois Kolkhorst, a Republican committee chair who has resurrected a 2023 invoice that will require new utility-scale photo voltaic and wind initiatives to get permits from the state’s Public Utility Fee, laws that are not imposed on initiatives for pure fuel and different power sources. The invoice additionally requires set-back necessities and cleanup funds.

Kolkhorst, in a press release to Stateline, referred to as the laws “a common-sense approach to the encroachment of wind and solar facilities being scattered across our great state with no consideration or safeguards for landowners or the environment.”

At an hourslong Senate committee listening to just lately the place opponents of Kolkhorst’s invoice outnumbered supporters, farmers, ranchers and small-town Texans typically discovered themselves on reverse sides, both arguing that sprawling wind farms and photo voltaic arrays are a long-lasting supply of financial vitality or a risk to a beloved lifestyle.

“The land isn’t just a piece of property to us,” stated Laurie Dihle, who lives on 154 acres in Franklin County together with her husband. “It’s our home, our sanctuary and a big part of who we are. When we look out across the road, we see rolling green pastures and trees. Now we’re facing the possibility of that view and so much more being replaced by a sprawling solar farm.”

Environmentalists and trade representatives view Kolkhorst’s invoice as a roadblock within the march towards inexperienced power. Luke Metzger, government director of Setting Texas, stated the invoice would open the door to “a really arbitrary discriminatory permitting regime,” requiring wind and photo voltaic builders to get permits that different power producers would not have to have.

Describing herself as a “lifelong wildlife conservationist,” Kolkhorst stated she launched the bipartisan invoice with 9 different senators in an effort that “looks past the billions in wind and solar subsidies to instead focus on the total impact of these projects on our land, people and wildlife.”

However oil and fuel initiatives can even hurt wildlife, and scientists observe that the emissions launched by fossil fuels worsen local weather change disasters.

Insiders following the laws, together with Metzger, determine one of many invoice’s main supporters as Kolkhorst donor Dan Friedkin, a billionaire Houston businessman.

Friedkin, chairman emeritus of the Texas Parks and Wildlife Fee, is proprietor and CEO of The Friedkin Group, a consortium of companies and investments that features Gulf States Toyota.

Gulf States is without doubt one of the world’s largest distributors of Toyota autos and elements, with unique rights to promote Toyotas in Texas and 4 different states. Gulf States Toyota Inc. State PAC made 4 donations totaling $42,500 to Kolkhorst from October of 2020 to October of 2024, in keeping with the Texas Ethics Fee.

Friedkin is a stunt pilot and outdoorsman with a ranch in South Texas. Neither he nor his lobbyist, Laird Doran, senior vp for public and authorized affairs at The Friedkin Group, returned cellphone calls from Stateline.

Texas lawmakers have filed dozens of wind- and solar-related payments this session, together with measures aimed toward limiting the location of battery storage amenities, curbing tax breaks and subsidies for renewable corporations and limiting the quantity of electrical energy photo voltaic and wind initiatives contribute to the state’s energy grid.

Republican state Sen. Phil King, for instance, is pushing a invoice that will mandate that fifty% of all new electrical energy should come from pure fuel, nuclear or battery storage. King stated photo voltaic and wind energy ought to be a part of the state’s power combine, however he claims they are not dependable sufficient to function the inspiration.

State Rep. Don McLaughlin, a Republican, has launched laws mandating a examine of the financial influence of wind and photo voltaic initiatives on native communities, in addition to noise and well being results, threats to wildlife and the challenges of disassembling worn-out programs. Sweetwater, Texas, has 1000’s of composite blades piled up in “a windmill graveyard.”

Rural help

However many rural GOP lawmakers whose districts way back sprouted oil rigs and pump jacks at the moment are robust supporters of wind and solar energy.

“It’s nonstop windmills on both sides of the road for 70 miles,” stated state Rep. John Smithee of Amarillo, describing a typical drive from his hometown within the Texas Panhandle to the Capitol in Austin. “Almost all of those (constituents) have benefited.”

State Rep. Drew Darby, whose northwest Texas district contains San Angelo and Water Valley, an unincorporated neighborhood of round 300, stated income from wind energy has resulted in countywide enhancements and lease funds to property house owners.

“It’s been a positive impact on rural effectiveness,” stated Darby. “Landowners … are receiving nice payments for leasing the property.”

In Water Valley, taxes from the elevated income paved the way in which for a tax-free bond election that enabled the city’s Ok-12 college so as to add an upscale weight room, a technical academic facility and a “cafetorium” that serves as a eating room and efficiency corridor. The college constructing had beforehand been so small that college students needed to eat in shifts.

The wind farm is predicted to generate $123 million in native taxes over the 30-year lifetime of the challenge, in addition to greater than $100 million in funds to landowners.

George Neill, the West Texas rancher, stated he takes the wind turbines in stride as he roams throughout his 1,700-acre unfold.

He isn’t at liberty to disclose the quantity of his funds. He isn’t getting wealthy, he stated, however the cash “makes a difference when you’re trying to run a ranch.”

2025 States Newsroom. Distributed by Tribune Content material Company, LLC.