After Spain’s blackout, questions about renewable energy are back

The large energy outage that hit the Iberian peninsula on April 28 has reignited a debate in Spain over the nation’s plan to part out its nuclear reactors because it generates extra energy with renewable power.

As individuals look ahead to solutions about what caused the historic power cutwhich abruptly disrupted tens of hundreds of thousands of lives, some are questioning the knowledge of decommissioning nuclear reactors that present a secure, if controversial, type of power in comparison with renewables, whose output will be intermittent.

Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez has rejected such criticism, asking for endurance whereas the federal government investigates what prompted the grid‘s disconnection. He stated that his authorities wouldn’t “deviate a single millimeter” from its power transition plans.

This is what to know in regards to the power debate:

What’s nuclear energy and why is it controversial?

Nuclear energy is a zero-carbon power supply shaped from nuclear fissionwhen the nuclei of atoms are break up into two or a number of elements, releasing power.

It accounts for about 10% of electricity generation worldwide, in line with the Worldwide Vitality Affiliation.

Many international locations contemplate nuclear energy essential to reaching their net-zero objectives. However whereas nuclear reactors don’t emit planet-warming greenhouse gases like gas- or coal-fired power plantsthey produce radioactive waste that even superior economies have struggled to dispose.

Why does Spain need to decommission its nuclear reactors?

Spain generated practically 57% of its electrical energy in 2024 from renewable energy sources like wind, hydropower and photo voltaic, in line with Crimson Eléctrica, the nation’s grid operator. About 20% got here from nuclear power plants.

In 2019, Sánchez’s authorities accredited a plan to decommission the nation’s remaining nuclear reactors between 2027 and 2035 because it expands its share of renewable power even additional. The nation goals to generate 81% of its electrical energy by 2030 from renewable sources.

Sánchez on Wednesday stated that the 4 nuclear services that have been on-line the day of the blackout didn’t assist re-power the grid.

Batteries and different strategies assist regulate modifications in electrical energy provide from wind and photo voltaic.

Why is Spain’s renewables push being questioned now?

Whereas the reason for the sudden outage on April 28 continues to be unknown, the occasion has raised questions in regards to the technical challenges going through electrical energy grids operating on excessive ranges of photo voltaic and wind.

Photo voltaic and wind offered roughly 70% of the electrical energy on the grid moments earlier than Spain misplaced 15 gigawatts of electrical energy—about 60% of its provide—in simply 5 seconds.

Electrical energy grids have been designed for a unique period, in line with Gilles Thonet, deputy secretary basic of the Worldwide Electrotechnical Fee, an trade group.

“Historically, energy flowed in a single route: from massive coal, fuel or nuclear plants to properties and companies,” Thonet stated. “These plants provided not only electricity, but also stability. Their spinning turbines acted like shock absorbers, smoothing out fluctuations in supply and demand.”

Within the days following the blackout, Google searches in Spain for “nuclear” spiked, in line with information from Google Tendencies.

Spain’s nuclear foyer group Foro Nuclear stated this week that the federal government ought to rethink its plan to decommission its nuclear reactors after the outage. Ignacio Araluce, its president, stated the nuclear crops on-line earlier than the outage “provide firmness and stability.”

Would extra nuclear energy have prevented a blackout?

Others say it’s too quickly to attract conclusions about what function nuclear power ought to play.

“We do not know the cause of the oscillations,” stated Pedro Fresco, director basic of Avaesen, an affiliation of renewable power and clear know-how companies in Valencia. “Therefore, we do not know what would have allowed them to be controlled.”

Spain’s grid operator final week narrowed down the supply of the outage to 2 separate incidents wherein substations in southwestern Spain failed.

Surroundings Minister Sara Aagesen stated earlier this week that the grid had initially withstood one other energy technology outage in southern Spain 19 seconds earlier than the blackout.

Sánchez in his speech to Parliament stated there was “no empirical evidence” to indicate that extra nuclear power on the grid may have prevented a blackout or allowed the nation to get again on-line quicker. Actually, the 4 nuclear facilities on-line on April 28 earlier than the blackout have been taken offline after the outage as a part of emergency protocol to keep away from overheating.

He stated that nuclear power “has not been shown to be an effective solution in situations like what we experienced on April 28,” and referred to as the controversy surrounding his authorities’s nuclear phase-out plan “a gigantic manipulation.”

Fuel and hydropower, in addition to electrical energy transfers from Morocco and France, have been used to get the nation’s grid again on-line.

© 2025 The Related Press. All rights reserved. This materials might not be printed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed with out permission.