Thoughts On Smaller Cars, Sustainability, & Technology

Join CleanTechnica’s Weekly Substack for Zach and Scott’s in-depth analyses and high level summariesjoin our daily newsletterand/or follow us on Google News!

I subscribe to Bloombergwhich day-after-day brings a bunch of reports and new concepts to my pc display screen. A couple of instances per week, I get an replace from Hyperdrivewhich focuses on vehicles. In the present day’s version started with this assertion: “Smaller cars are an obvious fix for crowded cities, limited resources and a warming planet. Yet they’ve become an endangered species, as tougher regulations made them uneconomical to produce and we gravitated towards muscular SUVs.”

I couldn’t agree extra. I’ve all the time most popular extra environment friendly smaller vehicles. I admit I as soon as owned a Ford Nation Squire LTD, which had room for a complete basketball crew and all their gear. With the center seat again folded down, an individual might stretch out and sleep within the again whereas another person drove, which made lengthy street journeys a breeze. However gasoline mileage was within the low teenagers more often than not.

Ford as soon as ran an advert claiming its massive sedans and wagons might get 18 mpg on a visit from Phoenix to Los Angeles. I really drove the precise route as soon as and acquired 18 mpg. It was the one time the automotive achieved that stage of gas economic system within the 4 years I owned it. I came upon later it’s barely downhill from Phoenix to LA. That’s the explanation Ford didn’t select to trumpet about gasoline mileage between New York and Chicago, apparently.

After the LTD, I principally drove smaller vehicles — generally a lot smaller, as was the case of the primary technology Honda Civic I purchased used. My pals laughed at its diminutive dimension, however when the primary gasoline disaster hit within the 70s, I used to be the one one who might drive to Canada — the place there have been no strains at gasoline stations — with out having to cease for gasoline. I graduated from that automotive to a primary technology Honda Accord, which might be thought-about small at present however was a midsize automotive again then. It was the quintessential three-door hatchback and it might do something — drive to Disney World or the Cabot Path whereas serving as my autocross and rally automotive. It all the time acquired 32 mpg or extra and I actually missed it after I traded it in.

After a number of years with a Dodge Colt, I “moved up” to four-door sedans — a succession of Saturn SL2s and Honda Civics, all of which had been snug and dependable however significantly smaller than the “small cars” being bought in America at present. The producers all the time inform us they solely construct what clients need and possibly they consider that. However yearly, their vehicles get a bit of greater and so they spend tens of millions on promoting to inform us how the most recent Belchfire 5000 has a tad extra leg room, a skosh extra head room, and a shtickel extra hip room than final 12 months’s mannequin.

The primary time I visited Europe, I used to be struck by how the typical automotive there was about 2/3 the dimensions of a mean automotive within the US. The folks had been slimmer and trimmer, too, which I suppose meant they weren’t as involved with hip room as People had been. However in recent times, European vehicles have gotten progressively bigger as SUV-itis has swept throughout the Continent. In the present day, gross sales of smaller vehicles — as soon as a mainstay of the European automotive enterprise — have dropped dramatically.

As Hyperdrive explains, security laws have lots to do with why European vehicles are getting bigger. Smaller vehicles and crumple zones aren’t shut pals. The crumple zones in new vehicles at present are bigger than the unique Fiat Cinquecento, the diminutive automotive that put Italian drivers again on the street after WW II.

A Name For New Laws For Smaller Automobiles

Bloomberg’s Albertina Torsoli experiences that in a joint interview with French newspaper Le Figaro final week, Stellantis Chair John Elkhorn and Renault CEO Luca de Meo mentioned extreme European Union regulation is inflating the price of making small vehicles as a result of they favor the manufacturing of bigger, heavier premium fashions. That in flip makes the manufacture of smaller vehicles unprofitable, which might result in layoffs and plant closures. Passenger automotive gross sales in Europe had been down 3 million automobiles in 2024, which places emphasis on their warnings.

“Between 2015 and 2030, the cost of a Clio will have increased by 40%,” de Meo mentioned. “European rules mean our cars are becoming always more complex, heavier, more expensive.” The Renault Clio has been one of many firm’s finest promoting vehicles, however it’s undoubtedly a small automotive. As costs go up, the hole between it and bigger vehicles will get smaller, which inspires some consumers to make the swap to a bigger automobiles because the distinction within the month-to-month cost is comparatively modest.

“There are too many rules designed for larger and more expensive cars, which does not allow us to make small cars under acceptable profitability conditions,” de Meo mentioned. “Is lane departure warning absolutely necessary in cars that spend 95% of their time in the city?” That know-how is changing into commonplace gear on many new vehicles, however is primarily meant to assist drivers throughout freeway driving. However it requires sensors and onboard cameras that push up the price of constructing a automotive.

Crash testing requirements additionally must be reviewed with a watch towards making a separate class for small vehicles. Beneath the present testing procedures, these smaller vehicles should carry out the identical as bigger vehicles with hoods which might be thrice longer, de Meo mentioned. Europe already has separate laws for quadricycles such because the Citroën am and Fiat Topolino. These vehicles are restricted to 45 km/h (28 mph) and price lower than €10,000.

The Kei Automobile Craze

Japan has its personal class for small, low powered automobiles lower than 3.4 meters (11 toes) lengthy with small inner combustion engines. Often called at vehicles, they usually weigh underneath 1000 kilos, but their security report is kind of good. They’re additionally a blast to drive. They account for almost 40% of all new automotive gross sales in a rustic the place city congestion is a lifestyle. At class vans could be imported into the US if they’re greater than 25 years previous and so they have turn into fairly in style in states the place they’re authorized.

Establishing one other regulatory class in Europe would possible be time-consuming, however “there’s no reason why Europe shouldn’t consider similar financial incentives for buyers of small cars, or penalize those who opt for a large SUV, or both,” Bloomberg says. “France has introduced weight-adjusted car taxes and parking charges,” whereas “changes to existing carbon-pollution targets could take into account the lower life cycle emissions associated with building smaller cars.”

At CleanTechnicawe’re staunch advocates for electrical automobiles, but when smaller and lighter vehicles had been to turn into a factor, that might be good too. A brand new firm known as Slatebacked by Jeff Bezos, says it would introduce a small electrical pickup truck that begins at $25,000 early subsequent 12 months. That’s of venture, contemplating most pickup vans within the US at present are nearer to twenty toes lengthy and tip the scales at 2½ tons.

If the recognition of at trucklets is any indication, that gamble might will repay. By the way, the identify of the corporate is supposedly an anagram of “Tesla,” so it’s protected to say the truck from Slate is supposed to be the “Anti-Cybertruck.” It may’t actually promote any worse than that Elon Musk mind fart, can it?