Do We Really Need Desert Solar Farms? It Depends.

Join daily news updates from CleanTechnica on electronic mail. Or follow us on Google News!

To essentially reply this query, let’s begin with a thought experiment.

If it have been fully as much as me, I’d promote my home, purchase a Silverado EV, and purchase two giant campers. One camper would solely be moved twice a yr between modest basecamps. One could be within the desert for the winter months, and the opposite could be within the mountains for the summer time months. The opposite could be used for normal journey. Each trailers could be completely lined in photo voltaic panels, have plenty of battery storage inside, and be principally self-sufficient powering an all-electric set of home equipment and HVAC gear.

The truck could be set as much as energy the touring camper at any time when solar energy fell brief, and extra photo voltaic that the camper’s batteries couldn’t take in could be used to cost the truck, taking full benefit of the large storage. Energy might even be “picked up” at charging stations for the campsite.

I’d even be free from sewer and water hookups through the use of composting bathrooms, water filtering from pure sources, and probably even some gray water recycling. I’d be virtually completely self-sufficient, by no means pay a utility invoice, and solely often pay for tenting house, and by no means owe lease, mortgage, or a automotive fee.

Ideally, this sort of a setup might be translated to constructions and methods of any measurement. A typical suburban home is quite a bit bigger than the typical camper, but additionally has much more roof house. The identical is true for warehouses, warehouse-style shops, and lots of different companies. Much more urbanized areas are likely to have plenty of house for panels on rooftops, over parking heaps, and probably even over streets and different public works.

The place The Issues Come Up

So, why don’t we simply put photo voltaic over every little thing, put batteries in all of the nooks and crannies, and energy every little thing from the smallest cities to the largest cities with clear power? The satan is within the particulars.

For one, there’s the issue of paying for it. There’s loads of cash being paid to utility corporations to finance solar energy buildouts, however no person desires to lease their roof to the native utility and the native utility doesn’t need to lease your roof. In most nations, the roof is personal property, and the proprietor of the roof (be it atop a suburban home or a skyscraper) finally ends up needing to pay for the photo voltaic. Not all people can’t afford this, and many individuals don’t even need it. Debt-to-income ratios make it robust for many individuals to afford a photo voltaic array even when it’s cheaper than what they’re paying the electrical firm.

One other drawback is that tall buildings don’t have a lot roof house. A skyscraper has plenty of room inside that wants heated, cooled, lit, and entertained, but it surely has little or no house on prime, making it robust for photo voltaic to maintain up. The perimeters of some buildings would possibly get solar, however vertical panels are much less superb and don’t generate sufficient energy to cowl the wants inside.

Lastly, not each metropolis or city is an efficient match for photo voltaic. Right here within the southwest the place I dwell, there’s loads of solar virtually on a regular basis, however elsewhere, it’s potential to have cloudy and wet climate for weeks at a time. Cities additional north get fewer hours of daylight daily, particularly within the winter months. There’s additionally tall vegetation in lots of locations that shades rooftops and parking heaps for a part of the day (one other factor I don’t have within the desert southwest). Even the terrain in some locations can shorten photo voltaic manufacturing time.

With all of those obstacles, it turns into mandatory to place no less than among the photo voltaic panels exterior of city and even in faraway locations the place situations are higher.

The Drawback With Placing Photo voltaic Panels On “Worthless” Desert Land

Letters to the Editor: California’s deserts are majestic. Assume earlier than masking them with photo voltaic farms https://t.co/7mBP0xbfvS

— Ileene Anderson (@AndersonIleene) October 20, 2024

Right here’s the factor: it’s simple to have a look at the desert and assume that it’s just like the floor of the moon. Some spots really appear like the moon, with no seen indicators of life, not even crops. So, in the event you dwell in a lush, inexperienced place, these deserts would possibly look like the best location for a photo voltaic farm. In any case, just some brief bushes and weeds are utilizing the land at most, and the daylight is about proper.

However, that’s a superficial means to have a look at the desert. Even in salt flats, there’s moisture and life beneath the floor. When it’s wetter, that life bursts forth on the floor and supplies a pit cease for birds making transcontinental journeys.

That is Nice Salt Lake as we speak close to Ogden Bay, east of the tip of Promontory Level. Just some months in the past it was fully dry. There’s just a few inches, but it surely’s maintaining the mud down AND creating habitat for a bazillion birds! Thanks @DucksUnlimited for the tour. pic.twitter.com/aTVYXY1x1Z

— Leia Larsen (@LeiaLarsen) April 12, 2023

How moist has it been in West Texas lately? Traces of Texas reader Christi Pearson was out close to the Guadalupe Mountains a lately and took this shot of the short-term lake that’s masking the large salt flat that’s on the market. 2nd picture is one in all my very own, displaying a traditional view. pic.twitter.com/D4172gmiRf

— Traces of Texas (@TracesofTexas) August 28, 2021

Regardless of the place you go within the desert, there’s hidden life and ecological worth. Tearing up giant areas and placing in photo voltaic panels means paying an environmental value of some form or one other. If nothing else, the pure magnificence (one thing individuals who don’t dwell within the desert have a tendency to understand extra) is misplaced when an excessive amount of of the panorama will get lined in photo voltaic farms. Leisure alternatives could be misplaced, and tourism can endure.

So, we don’t need to simply take the trail of least resistance and simply put the entire panels out within the desert.

A Higher, Extra Balanced Means Ahead

The actual fact is that many (however not all) of the obstacles to solar energy in city and suburban areas are a matter of public coverage and our monetary system and never pure limitations to the know-how working. As a substitute of giving up and pillaging the desert, we should always first attempt to dismantle these non-natural limitations.

Rooftop photo voltaic shouldn’t be one thing folks must take a standard mortgage out for. Capacity to pay one’s energy invoice must be proof sufficient {that a} photo voltaic system of an applicable measurement is in monetary attain. The entire different nonsense, like credit score scoring and debt-to-income ratios is foolish when you think about the apparent, confirmed potential to afford electrical energy.

One other factor that must be thought of is to make it simpler to let utilities lease house over buildings and parking heaps. Property house owners don’t all need to pay for photo voltaic or be concerned in that call. They produce other issues to do. However, if utilities might use a easy mechanism to only pay for the house, and a property proprietor might simply obtain a test each month with out having to elevate a finger, we’d see photo voltaic panels popping up in all places.

I’m positive readers have many different concepts, however the backside line is that this: we should always concentrate on constructing on land that has already been disrupted earlier than we exit disrupting extra land for clear power, no less than once we can.

Featured picture by Jennifer Sensiba.