State Farm & Other Insurance Companies Refuse Are Major Investors In Fossil Fuels

Join daily news updates from CleanTechnica on e mail. Or follow us on Google News!

Persons are starting to get up to the brand new actuality, which is that human-caused local weather change is rendering their properties uninsurable. With out insurance coverage, they face monetary wreck if a wildfire, hurricane, or different calamity destroys their property. The shortage of insurance coverage prevents individuals from acquiring loans to restore or rebuild their properties. It additionally makes it more durable to promote their properties to consumers who want a mortgage. However whereas it appears fully logical for insurance coverage firms to draw back from situations that carry increased than regular dangers, what is just not so logical is that the identical firms are additionally propping up the very fossil gas firms which can be the first explanation for the worldwide overheating.

Insure Our Future focuses on the insurance coverage trade’s ties to the local weather disaster. Risalat Khan, a senior strategist with Insure Our Future, advised Truthout not too long ago, “The insurance industry has the option of cutting exposure to fossil fuel expansion overnight, but rather than doing that, they’re continuing to play both sides.” There’s a broad consensus that world heating is driving the rise and depth of utmost climate occasions. The Intergovernmental Panel on Local weather Change (IPCC), has concluded as an “established fact” that “human-induced greenhouse gas emissions” have elevated the frequency and depth of utmost climate. It has additionally concluded with “high confidence” that fireplace climate situations “will become more frequent in some regions at higher levels of global warming.” Burning of fossil fuels is accountable “for over 75 percent of global greenhouse gas emissions and nearly 90 percent of all carbon dioxide emissions,” in response to the United Nations.

International heating is just not the only real driver of this insurance coverage trade disaster, however it might be the first one. A recent report by Insure Our Future discovered that “over one third of weather related insured losses over the last two decades, totaling $600 billion, can be attributed to climate change,” and that the “climate-attributed share of insured weather losses rose from 31% to 38% over the last decade on average.” But, many insurance coverage firms stay dedicated to propping up the fossil gas trade as each insurers and traders. The fossil gas trade couldn’t proceed with enterprise as normal, together with its ongoing enlargement, with out the crucial providers that insurance coverage firms present in underwriting every little thing from the buildout of oil pipelines to the development of liquefied pure gasoline (LNG) export amenities.

Insurance coverage Firms Play Each Sides Of The Road

A 2023 Insure Our Future report estimated {that a} small handful of insurance coverage giants, together with AIG, Chubb, and Liberty Mutual took in round $2.6 billion from fossil gas insurance coverage in 2022. A 2024 report by Public Citizen and Rainforest Motion Community confirmed how high insurers are extensively underwriting the Gulf Coast LNG export increase. Nonetheless, insurers don’t simply insure the operations of the fossil gas trade. They’re additionally large traders in these industries. A giant a part of the insurance coverage trade enterprise mannequin entails repackaging a piece of combination premium funds they absorb from shoppers as swimming pools of money to put money into monetary devices like shares and bonds. Prime insurers like State Farm have billions in oil and gasoline holdings and are among the many high shareholders of main oil firms similar to ExxonMobil and Chevron, at the same time as they refuse to resume hundreds of insurance coverage insurance policies.

Nor are insurance coverage firms minor traders, Truthout says. They’re enormous, multifaceted monetary establishments with over a half trillion {dollars} invested in fossil fuels.Some have main stakes in the identical oil and gasoline firms they’re underwriting, feeding the very excessive climate that’s producing a disaster in their very own trade. Khan calls this a “vicious cycle” the place insurers “are making the problem worse by investing and underwriting fossil fuel expansion, despite being exposed to paying out these losses.” Insurers do that with the idea that they’ll scale back their danger by non-renewing insurance policies or elevating premiums. “They’re making the risk worse and then charging more for those risks, or removing those from the balance sheets,” he mentioned. General, that “pushes the broader system towards these tipping points where we cannot manage these risks anymore and people don’t have the money to be able to pay for these costs.”

Massive Oil Pursuits

Scientists and world leaders have famous that local weather change doubtless intensified the Los Angeles fires, with “weather whiplash” and low soil and gas moisture ranges. Extra broadly, state businesses have reported extensively on the local weather disaster’s impression in California, affecting every little thing from coastal erosion and water provide to fireplace dangers and injury to agriculture. Fifteen of the twenty most harmful wildfires in California historical past have occurred during the last decade. On account of rising excessive climate occasions in California and the huge prices of insurance coverage payouts, firms have been curbing their enterprise within the state. In 2023, 7 of the highest 12 insurance coverage firms in California paused or restricted new insurance policies there.

Khan notes that firms like State Farm, Vacationers, AIG, Liberty Mutual, and others have concurrently pulled again from insuring Californians whereas additionally remaining wedded to fossil fuels. “These are all insurers that either have huge investments in fossil fuels or they’re underwriting fossil fuel expansion. With each of these companies, the hypocrisy is very visible.”

This insurance coverage crunch has a number of penalties, together with piling extra individuals into an already overburdened state insurance coverage plan, and driving up rental and prices of dwelling possession. On the identical time, high insurers in California stay dedicated to investing in fossil fuels. A 2023 briefing by Insure Our Future recognized a “dirty dozen” group of dwelling insurers, together with Berkshire Hathaway, State Farm, and Nationwide, which have restricted protection in California citing local weather dangers, however remained deeply embedded with the fossil gas trade. Collectively, they’ve an “estimated $113 billion of investments in and $3.6 billion of underwriting income from fossil fuels,” mentioned the briefing.

Final September, the Wall Street Journal reported that State Farm and Berkshire Hathaway, which additionally does in depth enterprise in California, “made multibillion dollar bets on major oil companies” that had been giant sufficient to assist offset a decline in fossil gas investments in different components of the trade. The investigation famous that State Farm and Berkshire “drove the industry’s overall exposure to fossil fuels higher, pushing it to 4.4% of their portfolios from 3.8%,” and that “the value of fossil fuel holdings by the property and casualty industry rose to $84.6 billion” in 2023 from $57 billion in 2014, pushed partly by the investments by these two firms.

A Truthout evaluation of State Farm’s most up-to-date SEC disclosure of its holdingsfiled in November 2024, lower than two months earlier than the Los Angeles fires began, exhibits continued enormous investments in fossil fuels. For instance, the disclosure reveals over $5.5 billion of holdings in two Massive Oil firms — $3,577,589,566 in ExxonMobil and $1,963,729,843 in Chevron. In accordance with the monetary information website WhaleWisdom.comthis makes State Farm among the many high 20 shareholders of each firms. The submitting additionally exhibits a $411,541,212 stake in Duke Power and $122,536,947 invested in Shell. State Farm additionally disclosed $86,443,949 value of holdings in Enbridge, the corporate behind the controversial Line 3 and Line 5 pipelines.

In the end, an enormous query looms over the insurance coverage trade — Is it actually value propping up the fossil gas trade at the same time as local weather chaos upends its personal enterprise? Amongst 28 main property and casualty insurers overseeing multiple third of the trade’s collective world market share, fossil gas premiums “represent under 2% of their total insurance premiums in 2023. “Why are insurers destabilizing the majority of their business for such a small fraction of revenue that they’re getting from fossil fuels?” asks Khan. “Does this really make economic sense for insurers?”

Khan takes some solace within the data that individuals are catching onto the role insurers play within the local weather disaster. Local weather and environmental justice organizers throughout the U.S. and past are more and more specializing in insurance coverage giants. “The insurance industry could be one of the biggest positive forces in the climate story,” mentioned Khan. “They can look at their fossil fuel clients and say, we’re not going to insure their reckless expansion plans anymore, because this is too costly for us and it’s too costly for everyone.”

Folks may additionally vote with the wallets to deselect State Farm and the opposite insurance coverage firms when contemplating who to do enterprise with (assuming they produce other choices obtainable). They may additionally push again in opposition to well-liked sports figures like Patrick Mahomes and Andy Reid of the Kansas Metropolis Chiefs who shill for State Farm of their commercials. Each have greater than sufficient cash and don’t must prostitute themselves for an organization that’s intentionally selling the local weather emergency. Disgrace on each of them.