Tesla Chair Robyn Denholm Decides To Dummy Up When Asked About Elon Musk

Join daily news updates from CleanTechnica on e mail. Or follow us on Google News!

Final Up to date on: twenty fifth March 2025, 06:12 pm

What obligation — if any — does the chair of the board of administrators of a publicly traded firm must touch upon the actions of the company’s largest stockholder and CEO? Robyn Denholm has been the chair of the Tesla board since November 2018. Since then, plenty of water has flowed below the bridge at Tesla. At one time, it was on a path to double the variety of automobiles it produced yearly, however issues have turned bitter currently, with gross sales in some international locations down over 40 % or extra.

Up to now 12 months, Elon Musk, who owns essentially the most shares of Tesla and is the wealthiest particular person within the historical past of the world, determined to embrace the authoritarian insurance policies of the the Republican nominee for president of the US and turn into the loudest voice within the MAGAlomaniac motion. He contributed over $300 million to the election marketing campaign of the present occupant of the Offal Workplace, exhorted Germans to recover from the Nazi factor, excoriated the British authorities, and disparaged Canada steadily. He complained bitterly that those that don’t see the world from his distorted and disturbed perspective are contaminated with a “woke mind virus,” by no means stopping to assume that in a pluralist society, not everybody will see the world in the identical method.

Many imagine Musk’s tirades are the first purpose why Tesla gross sales are declining whereas gross sales of electrical automobiles from different producers are choosing up velocity. There are different causes, in fact. Tesla has refused to convey new fashions to market regardless of the urgings of its most senior engineers as a result of Musk merely refused to take action. He has put all his eggs within the robotaxi basket. Though, a revised and less expensive model of the Mannequin Y is now on the horizon.

Denholm Dodges All Questions

On March 25, 2025, Denholm was in Melbourne, Australia, to deal with a monetary providers convention in her function because the chair of the Tech Council of Australia. On her method into the convention venue, Denholm studiously ignored questions on Tesla and Musk. When requested if she was involved about Musk’s right-wing allegiances or his opposition to variety, fairness and inclusion initiatives, she declined to reply. Requested if she had a message for Tesla shareholders, she didn’t reply. A girl accompanying Denholm mentioned they might not remark or reply to any questions. She then went on to offer a keynote speech that targeted on Australia’s insufficient funding in analysis and growth. Nothing within the speech pertained to Tesla or her function as chair of the board of administrators for Tesla.

Bloomberg has termed her silence as a missed alternative to deal with all method of crises swirling round Tesla. Musk’s function as a high adviser to the present US president has made Tesla a goal for protests and vandalism at house and overseas. The billionaire CEO’s actions and social media exercise are alienating would-be consumers and main homeowners of Tesla automobiles to distance themselves from his politics and the corporate’s broken model. Shortly after Denholm’s look, the European Car Producers’ Affiliation mentioned Tesla’s gross sales within the area plunged 40% in February. The corporate’s 43% drop within the first two months of the 12 months appears all of the extra abysmal when put next with the 31% rise in industry-wide registrations of latest EVs.

The time and a spotlight Musk has been devoting to the so-called Division of Authorities Effectivity has exacerbated considerations that the he’s stretched too skinny and devoting inadequate time to Tesla. Even earlier than Musk started overseeing efforts to purge federal staff and intestine authorities companies, Tesla was one among six corporations he was main — the others being SpaceX, X, xAI, The Boring Firm, and Neuralink. Musk, with a greater than $340 billion fortune, informed Fox Enterprise earlier this month that he was having “great difficulty” operating his companies in parallel with all he’s been as much as in Washington. He sought to reassure Tesla staff throughout a gathering final week and urged them to hold on to their inventory. That recommendation doesn’t appear to pertain to Denholm, nevertheless.

The Financial Review experiences that, so far, she has cashed in about $532 million price of Tesla shares, in line with Equilar, which analysed dozens of regulatory filings concerning her compensation and inventory gross sales over her time on the board. A few of these gross sales got here as just lately as early March, making her the very best paid board member of a giant public company. Along with her wealth has come criticism of her compensation — and pointed questions on whether or not the windfall is compromising her oversight of Tesla and the billionaire who enriched her.

A Choose Has Questions

In her ruling final 12 months, the Delaware decide who rejected Musk’s compensation package recommended that Denholm’s profitable board pay had hindered her means to carry out her duties. “Ordinary, market rate compensation does not compromise a director’s independence. Outsized director compensation can,” wrote Chancellor Kathaleen McCormick of the Delaware Courtroom of Chancery. The decide particularly recommended that Denholm lacked independence as a result of she owed most of her wealth to her providers as a Tesla director. She raked in $280 million exercising Tesla choices simply in 2021 and 2022, a sum she described as “life-changing.”

In her few public remarks concerning the potential battle of curiosity posed by her outsized earnings, Denholm has mentioned her newfound wealth makes her much less beholden to Musk, no more. In an interview with the Monetary Instances final Could, she dismissed Choose McCormick’s criticism of her tenure as chair as “crap,” saying, “If I didn’t agree with something that was going on at the company, I could walk away tomorrow.” Which may be so, but some would argue she has finished subsequent to nothing to earn her compensation, particularly in relation to addressing the harm Musk has finished to the model since he bought Twitter.

Denholm’s look on the Asia Pacific Monetary and Innovation Symposium in Melbourne is perhaps her final as chair of the Tech Council of Australia — the hat she often wears for public appearances in her house nation — after just lately saying she would cede the function to Scott Farquhar, co-founder of software program firm Atlassian. One of many Symposium’s initiatives has been to extend the variety of ladies working within the tech {industry}.

It introduced a program earlier this month with a number of corporations that may “highlight the benefit of tech careers and the promotion of gender, equity, and inclusion in the tech sector.” That place is opposite to Musk’s stance on DEI, which he has referred to as “just another word for racism.” He has additionally written and amplified posts on X blaming every little thing from the Los Angeles wildfires to Boeing’s manufacturing lapses on DEI insurance policies. By her silence, Denholm is enabling Musk and undercutting her personal beliefs. However that’s OK; she is laughing all the way in which to the financial institution.