EVs Take 24.1% Share In France — Popular BEVs Hit By Incentive Stop

Join daily news updates from CleanTechnica on e mail. Or follow us on Google News!

Might’s auto gross sales noticed plugin EVs take 24.1% share in France, roughly flat from 24.3% year-on-year. BEV share was up, whereas PHEV share dropped. General auto quantity was 141,298 items, down by some 3% YoY. The Peugeot e-208 now has a robust lead within the BEV rankings.

Might’s outcomes noticed mixed plugin EVs take 24.1% share in France, comprising 16.9% full battery-electrics (BEVs), with 7.2% plugin hybrids (PHEVs). These examine with YoY figures of 24.3% mixed, with 15.6% BEV, and eight.7% PHEV.

Should you’ve been following our French market stories this 12 months, you’ll do not forget that there have been two major forces at play within the BEV market in current months.

The primary was the March fifteenth cancellation of the eco-bonus for BEVs made outdoors Europe. This included most of the hottest BEVs; Tesla Mannequin 3, Dacia Spring, Kia Niro, Kia EV6, BYD Atto 3, Volvo EX30, MG4, Ford Mach-e, Fisker Ocean, Nissan Ariya, Toyota BZ4X, and plenty of others.

The elimination of the bonus for these fashions has successfully blocked (or severely smothered) a few of the least costly BEVs (e.g. Dacia Spring, MG4) and a few of one of the best worth BEVs (e.g. Volvo EX30, Tesla Mannequin 3) from the market. The top result’s that the spectrum of BEVs that stay now accommodates fewer inexpensive choices, and fewer good-value choices, than beforehand. Not nice.

The second power at play has been the social leasing programme which ran from January to mid February, and managed to enroll 50,000 new BEV lease contracts (twice the deliberate quantity). The contracted BEVs weren’t sometimes delivered “at signing” however as an alternative, with some wait time (a number of weeks to a couple months). For instance, April saw a strong bump in BEV registrations (up 44.9% in quantity 12 months on 12 months), which was virtually actually an impact of the social leasing programme.

Nonetheless, most of these 50,000 leased items have in all probability made their means by to deliveries by now, and we all know that after a “pull forward” impact, there’s sometimes a consequent “hangover” impact.

Add to that hangover, the stopping of the eco-bonus for a lot of in style BEVs, and what do you get? A depressed BEV market. I count on the slowing YoY quantity progress we see in Might is a part of this, at simply 5.4% (in comparison with the 27.7% January to April common). Doubtless June (and maybe July, and August) will even see unimpressive YoY progress, or maybe even detrimental progress. Let’s control this.

Past BEVs, most different powertrains have been down in quantity YoY, aside from HEVs (plugless hybrids and mild-hybrids), which have been up by a robust 38%. Doubtless most of those are 12 volt or 48 volt “mild hybrids”, that are a really low cost (and non permanent) repair for producers to fulfill tightening emissions guidelines.

In the meantime, PHEVs gross sales volumes have been down YoY by 19%, petrol-only down by 20%, diesel-only down by 25%.

Finest Promoting BEVs

The Peugeot e-208 has been one of the best promoting BEV in France for each month of the 12 months to this point. Might noticed it ship 2,882 items.

In second place was the Renault Twingo, with 1,688 items, and its sibling the Renault Megane got here in third, with 1,614 items.

It’s seemingly that all the high three are strongly benefitting from remaining supply items from the social leasing scheme.

Their elevated rank can be a consequence of the cancellation of the non-European BEVs famous above: within the closing quarter of 2023, none of those now-top-3 fashions even appeared within the high six, not to mention within the high 3. Again then, the Tesla Mannequin 3, Tesla Mannequin Y, Dacia Spring, and MG4 have been recurrently dominating. As of Might, solely the European-made Tesla Mannequin Y stays close to the highest now, the Mannequin 3 is relegated to tenth, the MG4 to nineteenth, and the Dacia Spring has disappeared completely!

We don’t have entry to deep sufficient market information to detect the hint volumes of any potential new BEV fashions debuting on the French market. See our different European reports for the regional image on rising fashions, that are prone to now (or quickly) be on sale in France additionally.

Let’s take a step again to overview the long term rankings:

The traits shaping the trailing 3 months rankings are just like these shaping the month-to-month. The Tesla Mannequin Y was not a part of the social leasing programme, so it has dropped to second place for the reason that December to February interval. The Peugeot 208 has stepped up as a substitute to take the lead.

Hit by the double whammy of the leasing and the motivation cancellation, the Tesla Mannequin 3 has fallen from 2nd within the prior interval, now right down to seventh. The Mannequin 3 will seemingly fall additional, since this era continues to be propped up by a good March, when it managed to make okay gross sales simply previous to the motivation cancellation.

The MG4 is in the identical boat. It’s now right down to thirteenth spot, from 4th within the prior interval. Once more, March noticed okay gross sales, so this 3-month window continues to be propped up considerably.  The MG4 will battle to remain within the high 20 going forwards. With a degree enjoying discipline, the MG4 is likely one of the most compelling and finest worth BEVs on sale in Europe – French customers are worse off now that it has been boxed in.

The Dacia Spring is in even worse form. Within the December to February interval, it was in fifth spot. Now it has disappeared virtually completely. It had simply 148 gross sales in March, after which a pitiful 35 gross sales in April and Might mixed. This can be a nice disgrace, as a result of over the previous 3 years, the Spring was periodically the month-to-month finest vendor in France.

When the extent enjoying discipline was in place, the Spring was additionally the one BEV in Europe that may very well be referred to as roughly “affordable” on an absolute foundation, and was cherished by French customers, simply as inexpensive classics just like the Citroen 2CV, and Renault 4, have been cherished by earlier generations of French drivers.

There’s been loads of pleasure concerning the upcoming Citroen e-C3, which is because of begin buyer deliveries within the subsequent 2 or 3 months (September on the newest). The C3 has a good steadiness of specs for an entry BEV, with 44 kWh usable LFP battery (45 kWh gross), and respectable effectivity. In beneficial climate situations, it ought to have the ability to repeatedly cowl 2 hours of smart freeway or rural driving, between DC charging stops of simply over half-hour. This period of charging and driving cycle is greater than ok for a lot of Europeans who solely make lengthy journeys very sometimes, particularly in areas with respectable DC infrastructure. In brief – the automobile itself is all nicely and good.

Nonetheless, whereas the pricing (from €23,300) may seem like good in relative phrases, given sometimes excessive European BEV pricing, in actuality, the e-C3 continues to be far overpriced given the low value of BEV parts. LFP cells now cost just €49 per kWhand a forty five kWh battery pack might be produced for underneath €3,000. The Citroen C3’s built-in 3-in-1 drive unit (83 kW peak) might be sourced for underneath €2,000 in massive orders, with just a few hundred extra for different energy electronics and controls.

Altogether, this provides as much as nicely underneath €6,000 in BEV-specific powertrain prices. Then there are the financial savings of a minimum of €1,500 to €2,500 from avoiding the ICE, transmission, emissions management system, and different ICE ancillaries. Realistically the fee premium for the BEV over the ICE variant shouldn’t be greater than ~€4,000.

Why then in France and Germany does the BEV variant get priced from €23,300 MSRP, while the ICE variant is priced from  €14,990 MSRP – a distinction of €8,310? To me this over-inflated pricing is simply one other instance of legacy auto firms conserving their foot on the brake of the BEV transition. Please share your ideas on this within the feedback part.

Outlook

Trying previous the weak auto market, France’s broader economic system noticed 1.1% YoY growth in Q1 2024. That is far more healthy than the Euro-area common of 0.4% in Q1, not to mention the detrimental progress in neighbours comparable to Germany (-0.2%), the Netherlands (-0.7%), and Norway (-0.8%).

Inflation was flat at 2.2% in Might, and rates of interest lastly diminished to 4.25% after 7 months at 4.5%. Manufacturing PMI was 46.3 factors, from 45.3 factors in April.

As mentioned above, the approaching months will seemingly see a hangover associated to the tailing-off of the social leasing deliveries, and the persevering with lack of incentives on non-European BEVs, which have been beforehand essentially the most inexpensive and finest worth BEVs accessible. We’ll control how these dynamics affect the market.

What are your ideas on France’s auto market and transition to EVs? Please be a part of within the dialogue beneath.